Is scavenging worth it in Probably Stolen?
What one night pays
A night that needs a bandage brings about ₵53 on sale. The lost walk-in customer is worth about ₵20.
Mark Up, 5 searches, finds sold to normal buyers at value plus 15%. Worked over 40,000 simulated nights per row with the game's loot tables, wound chances, bag grids and item sizes. All values in credits.
| Setup | Nights with a wound | Brought home (₵) | On sale (+15%) (₵) | Net after bandage (₵) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pockets only, no bag | 35% | 42 | 48 | 45 |
| Fanny Pack | 35% | 49 | 56 | 53 |
| Satchel (Small) or any bigger bag | 35% | 52 | 60 | 57 |
| Fanny Pack and a Flashlight | 20% | 55 | 63 | 61 |
| Fanny Pack on a Fresh Dump Wednesday | 42% | 61 | 70 | 66 |
| Careful + Proficient Scavenger, Fanny Pack | 0 | 61 | 70 | 70 |
| Careful + Proficient Scavenger, Kid's Backpack (Large) | 0 | 65 | 75 | 75 |
| Georgio's help night (10 safe), Kid's Backpack (Large) | 0 | 125 | 143 | 143 |
| Georgio's help on a Wednesday, Kid's Backpack (Large) | 0 | 162 | 187 | 187 |
- Net after bandage takes off one Basic Bandage (value 8, about 9 at your shelf price) for each wound.
- From day 14, take off about 20 more for the walk-in you miss next morning. Before day 14 nothing is lost.
- Do not sell finds to the Merchant. He pays value minus 15% and only comes on Sundays and now and then. Keep unsold finds in stock for the next normal buyer.
How a search works
- The panel shows Attempts Remaining and the wound chances for the next search. Search 1 is 5% minor and 1% major. Each later search adds 1 and 0.25.
- The game rolls a minor wound first, then a major one.
- A wound ends the night at once, and that search finds nothing. The searches you already made keep their finds.
- If no wound, you roll one loot table, then one item in it, plus small extras.
| Search | Minor wound (percent) | Major wound (percent) | Minor on Wednesday | Major on Wednesday |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 5.00 | 1.00 | 6.25 | 1.25 |
| 2 | 6.00 | 1.25 | 7.50 | 1.56 |
| 3 | 7.00 | 1.50 | 8.75 | 1.88 |
| 4 | 8.00 | 1.75 | 10.00 | 2.19 |
| 5 | 9.00 | 2.00 | 11.25 | 2.50 |
- What the game code says about a wound: the search that wounds you finds nothing, and a fresh wound ends scavenging for that night. Bandage it when you are home.
- Why a normal night finds 52, not 65. Five searches with no wound would find 5 x 13.1 = 65. About one night in three ends early, and a wound on search 1 sends you home with nothing.
- Your first two trips are safe. With the intro on, your first 10 searches of a run cannot give a minor wound and your first 20 cannot give a major one. Trips 1 and 2 bring home about 61 with the Fanny Pack; trips 3 and 4 can only give a minor wound. Skip Intro starts have no grace.
What a search finds
| Table | Chance | Average value (₵) |
|---|---|---|
| Junk (mostly Junk worth ₵3) | 65 | 4.7 |
| Materials (Scrap Metal to Kotton Fabric) | 15 | 22.4 |
| Medical (bandages) | 5 | 13.3 |
| Household | 4.75 | 28.3 |
| Packed food | 4.75 | 21.9 |
| Tools | 2 | 59.2 |
| Makeshift weapons | 2 | 24.0 |
| Basic modules | 1 | 64.2 |
| Advanced modules | 0.5 | 90.0 |
The arithmetic for one search
- Main roll: 0.65 x 4.71 + 0.15 x 22.38 + 0.05 x 13.33 + 0.0475 x 28.25 + 0.0475 x 21.88 + 0.02 x 59.17 + 0.02 x 24 + 0.01 x 64.25 + 0.005 x 90 = 12.2.
- Extras: a corrupted cassette (1%, 35) and a Mouse Trap (1%, 50) add 0.85, for 13.1 a search.
- A Screwdriver, Wire Cutter and Plasma Cutter carried at night each add a 10% chance of Metal Screws, Wire or Scrap Metal: about +4 a search for all three.
- A Scav Scanner carried at night gives a 15% chance of a second full roll: about +1.8 a search.
- While you have not found them yet, each search has a 3% chance of a Satchel (Small), then of a Kid's Backpack. Each comes once a run.
The bag you take
Take a bag: the Fanny Pack beats bare pockets by about ₵8 on sale a night. A bigger bag adds about ₵4 more.
| Bag | Grid (cells) | Where you get it | Brought home, normal night (₵) | Brought home, Georgio's help night |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pockets only | 2 items | Always | 42 | 76 |
| Fanny Pack | 3 by 3 | The Mentor, day 2, free | 49 | 106 |
| Satchel (Small) | 6 by 3 | A 3% find a search; Dr. Jackson sells one | 52 | Not worked out |
| Kid's Backpack | 5 by 5 | A 3% find, after the Satchel | 52 | Not worked out |
| Kid's Backpack (Large) | 5 by 6 | Georgio, day 12, ₵150 | 52 | 125 |
- Can you carry Junk without a bag? Barely. Each Pocket holds one item of any size, so pockets only means you keep your 2 best finds. A normal night makes about 4 finds; the other 2, worth about ₵11 (mostly Junk at ₵3), stay on the Ground.
- The Fanny Pack is small. Its 3 by 3 grid takes about one find: Junk and Scrap Metal are 3 by 2, a Box Cutter (4 by 1) never fits. So it keeps about 3 of your 4 finds, with the Pockets.
- Any bag from the Satchel (Small) up keeps everything on a normal night. Only Georgio's 10-search nights fill one.
- The Kid's Backpack (Large) pays on Georgio's help nights: about 75 more on sale over his 3 nights than the Fanny Pack. It resells to the Merchant for 212, more than its 150 price.
The sizes come from the game's item pictures, measured as rectangles. Items with empty corners may pack a little tighter.
The cost: the customer you lose
From day 14, a night out removes one walk-in customer the next day. At the starting shop that is 1 of your 2 walk-ins. Short Sleeper is the only fix. Before day 14 no walk-ins come at all, so early nights cost nothing.
How much is one walk-in worth?
- About 20 of profit around day 14, about 25 by day 30 and about 30 by day 50.
- Why about 20: about 6 walk-ins in 10 are sellers. A seller's lot is worth about ₵90 + 2 x the day, and reselling it clears about 26.5%. On day 14: 0.6 x 0.265 x 118 = about 19.
- Those numbers come from the game's customer pools and our shop model, matched to our playthrough's trade.
- Net from day 14: Fanny Pack 53 - 20 = about 33 a night. Careful + Proficient with the Kid's Backpack (Large) 75 - 20 = about 55.
- When to stop for good: only when a walk-in earns you more than a night's finds. With the Fanny Pack that is about day 120 in our shop model.
When to go out, and when to stay home
| When | What to do | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Days 1 to 13 | Go every night | No customer lost. Your first two trips cannot wound you |
| Every Wednesday | Go, it is the best night | Fresh Dump: less Junk |
| Day 14 on | Go on any night you have nothing better to do | A night still pays about ₵33 over the lost customer (55 with the perks and a big bag) |
| The door will not let you out | Bandage, sleep, try the next night | You carry more than 5 wound points |
| A night you need elsewhere | Go there instead | One place a night: the Commissary, Dr. Jackson, the Exchange |
Wounds and bandages
The game shows no wound number. Count it yourself: a minor wound is 2 points, a major one 5. Above 5, the shop door will not let you out at night.
| What happened | Your points | Can you go out? |
|---|---|---|
| One minor wound | 2 | Yes |
| Two minor wounds | 4 | Yes |
| One major wound | 5 | Yes, but one more wound of any kind stops you |
| Three minor, or a major and a minor | 6 or more | No: bandage and wait |
- Bandage every wound the same night. A fresh wound is unstable: each night it has a 10% chance to get 1 point worse, otherwise a 50% chance to settle. A bandage settles it at once.
- A settled wound heals 4 points a night. So a bandaged minor wound is gone after one night, and a bandaged major one after two.
- The Basic Bandage (value 8) only settles a wound. Hemostatic and Topical Medication Bandages (16) also heal 1.
- A Flashlight halves both wound chances. Careful Scavenger or Georgio's help makes them 0.
- Rule of thumb: keep one bandage in your bag, use it on any wound, and you can go out every night.
Perks and Georgio's help
| Setup | Searches | Wounds | On sale a night (₵) | Net after bandage (₵) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| No perk, Fanny Pack | 5 | 35% of nights | 56 | 53 |
| Careful Scavenger only, Fanny Pack | 3 | none | 45 | 45 |
| Proficient Scavenger only, Kid's Backpack (Large) | 7 | 51% of nights | 75 | 71 |
| Careful + Proficient, Kid's Backpack (Large) | 5 | none | 75 | 75 |
| Georgio's help (day 15, 50 for 3 nights), Kid's Backpack (Large) | 10 | none | 143 | 143 |
Why Georgio's help is 30 safe searches
- Paying him 50 starts a 3-night help event. Each night gives 5 extra searches and no wounds: two separate effects.
- 5 normal + 5 extra = 10 searches a night, x 3 nights = 30 searches that cannot wound you.
- The nights are days 15, 16 and 17, and day 17 is a Fresh Dump Wednesday. With the Kid's Backpack (Large): 143 + 143 + 187 = about 473 on sale. With the Fanny Pack: 122 + 122 + 154 = about 398. Not yet verified
- Three normal nights in a Fanny Pack net about 53 + 53 + 66 = 172, so the help gains you about 300 for 50.
Fresh Dump Wednesday
Every Wednesday the Junk share is halved and wound chances rise by a quarter.
| Normal night | Wednesday | |
|---|---|---|
| Junk share of rolls | 65% | about 48% |
| Nights with a wound | 35% | 42% |
| Value of one safe search (credits) | 13.1 | 16.4 |
What Wednesday adds, in credits on sale:
| Setup | Normal night (₵) | Wednesday (₵) | Wednesday adds (₵) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fanny Pack | 56 | 70 | +14 (25%) |
| Kid's Backpack (Large) | 60 | 73 | +13 (21%) |
| Careful + Proficient, Fanny Pack | 70 | 91 | +21 (30%) |
| Careful + Proficient, Kid's Backpack (Large) | 75 | 96 | +21 (28%) |
| Georgio's help night, Fanny Pack | 122 | 154 | +32 (27%) |
| Georgio's help night, Kid's Backpack (Large) | 143 | 187 | +44 (30%) |
A Wednesday is the best night to scavenge, and best of all when you are safe from wounds: then it pays ₵20 to ₵45 more.
Luck
Your Luck is a percent chance that a wound is cancelled. At 75 Luck, three wounds in four never happen. A cancelled wound finds nothing, but the night goes on. Luck does not change what you find.
| Your Luck | From | Nights with a wound | On sale a night (Fanny Pack) (₵) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | Nothing | 35% | 56 |
| 15 | Lucky perk | 31% | 58 |
| 20 | Lucky + Gambler's Coin | 29% | 58 |
| 75 | Liquid Luck | 10% | 62 |
| 95 | All three, the most possible | 2% | 65 |
| -15 | Unlucky perk | 36%, plus 15% of searches come up empty | 49 |
- +75 Luck elsewhere: loot crate chances x 1.75, scratcher symbols match the lucky one 35% of the time instead of 20, and the lottery gets a 75% chance of a second draw.
- More Liquid Luck bottles add days, not Luck. One bottle is +75 Luck for 3 days, three are +75 Luck for 9 days.
- A bottle is worth about ₵25 of extra scavenging over its 3 days (about 6 more on sale and 2 less in bandages a night). It sells for about ₵115 to a Tourist, so drink it before crates and scratchers instead.
How to scavenge
- Close the shop for the night after your last customer.
- Hold the left door for about 2 seconds until "Leave the Store" completes, then pick a bag in the "Select a Backpack To Take" window.
- Click the Dumping Ground card on the Station Rapid Transit map and press Travel.
- Search up to your limit on the Dumping Ground panel. Read the wound chances before each search.
- Drag your best finds from the Ground into the Backpack and the two Pockets. Each Pocket takes one item. Anything left on the Ground is lost.
- Press Return.
- Put the finds on your shelf for matching buyers. Only things nobody buys (Tip 3 on the Top tips page) go to the Merchant.
More answers
Sources for this page: the game's own data, community players, our own play, our estimates; community sources: wikily.gg.