Haggling and the Bargain panel
✕The answer: haggling is a one-shot gamble with fixed odds, not a back-and-forth. At neutral reputation it loses you money to push a price up, but it is a cheap way to widen a customer's budget.
How it works
- Unlocks: the Mentor's bargaining lesson is on day 8 (skipping the intro unlocks it at once). Threaten unlocks on day 12.
- Steps: 10, 25, 50 and 75%.
- One choice per pair, rolled once per customer. There is no counter-offer ladder and no patience meter. A customer leaves only on a failed roll, a failed Blackmail or Threaten, or when dismissed.
- Once tried, a pair is closed for that customer. One bargain covers every item on the counter, including items added later.
- The button is hidden with the Awful Negotiator perk (it also takes 5 off your price), outside the shop, and for customers who refuse haggling.
- Tooltips on the buttons read "Accepts: N%", "Refuses: N%", "Walks out: N%" or "Always accepted". They add "+N% accept chance from Deal Maker" when one is running.
Each pair has one sure option and one gamble:
| Pair | When you sell | When you buy |
|---|---|---|
| The sure thing (always accepted) | Offer Discount | Offer Markup (you pay more) |
| The gamble | Add Markup | Demand Discount |
The odds at neutral reputation (no event, no Deal Maker)
At neutral reputation the 10% step is accepted 80% of the time. The 50 and 75% steps are never accepted.
| Step | Accepted | Rejected, customer stays | Walks out (sale lost, -3 rep) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 10% | 80% | 8% | 12% |
| 25% | 50% | 20% | 30% |
| 50% | 0% | 40% | 60% |
| 75% | 0% | 10% | 90% |
What raises the odds (added to both the accept and the stay limits):
- Faction reputation divided by 6, cut to a whole number and doubled when negative. Each +6 reputation adds 1 and each -6 takes 2.
- Plus 15 for event customers.
- A Deal Maker adds about 10 to the accept chance only.
Example: reputation 30 (+5%), an event customer (+15%) and the 25% step give 70% accepted and 10% walking out.
Never haggle with these: Augs, Dr. Jackson, the Hypertech Smuggler, the Clinic Volunteer, Eleanor's Uncle, couriers, the Landlord's wholesale visit, gun orders, Lou's demands and barter offers. Augs always refuse markups and discounts without a roll, but the option is still used up.
Is it worth it? Worked example
The answer: at neutral reputation, skip Add Markup. Every step returns less than a plain sale.
A customer buys one item with a base value of 200. Retail markup puts it at 230 with no haggle.
| Add Markup | New price (₵) | Accept / stays / walks | Expected sale (₵) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 10% | 253 | 80 / 8 / 12 | 0.80 x 253 + 0.08 x 230 = 221 |
| 25% | 288 | 50 / 20 / 30 | 190 |
| 50% | 345 | 0 / 40 / 60 | 92 |
| 75% | 402 | 0 / 10 / 90 | 23 |
The general rule. Expected value as a share of the plain price = (1 + step) x accept + stay. Work it out in percent:
- accept = 100 - 2 x step + bonus
- stay = the gap up to 100 - 1.2 x step + bonus
- bonus = reputation / 6 cut to a whole number, plus 15 for an event customer
| Situation (Add Markup) | 10% step | 25% step | 50% step | 75% step |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Neutral reputation | 96% | 83% | 40% | 10% |
| Reputation 24 (bonus +4%) | 100% | 88% | 46% | 14% |
| Reputation 30 (bonus +5%) | 102% | 89% | 48% | 15% |
| Event customer (+15%), reputation 0 | 110% | 101% | 63% | 25% |
| Event customer and reputation 30 | 110% | 108% | 70% | 30% |
| Deal Maker at quality 0 (+10% accept), reputation 0 | 99% | 85% | 45% | 10% |
- Break-even for the 10% step is reputation 24 with that customer's faction (bonus +4% gives 100.4%). Below that you lose on average.
- Event customers are the one case where haggling pays at neutral reputation: the 10% step returns 109.5% of the plain price. A Foreman, Panic Buyer or Corporate Buyer is an event customer. Ordinary walk-ins and case buyers are not.
- The Deal Maker barely helps, and cannot be obtained. It raises only the accept limit, not the stay limit, so at the 10% step it just trades "stays" for "accepts" and returns 99%. It is worth owning only with reputation or an event customer on the other side.
- Ignored in the table: an accepted Add Markup cuts the buyer's remaining budget by 10, 15, 20 or 25% (steps 10, 25, 50, 75) and turns that trade's reputation negative.
Offer Discount is the useful tool
Offer Discount is always accepted and raises the customer's budget by twice the percentage. It also adds to the trade's reputation.
| Price cut | Budget rise |
|---|---|
| -10% | +20% |
| -25% | +50% |
| -50% | +100% |
| -75% | +150% |
Use it only when you hold more goods than the buyer's budget covers. Revenue = the smaller of (budget x (1 + 2 x step)) and (goods at list x (1 - step)).
| Budget ₵750, goods worth ₵1,200 at list | Budget after (₵) | Goods after (₵) | You are paid |
|---|---|---|---|
| No discount | 750 | 1,200 | 750 (450 of goods left over) |
| 10% off | 900 | 1,080 | 900 |
| 25% off | 1,125 | 900 | 900 (all goods gone) |
| 50% off | 1,500 | 600 | 600 |
With a 750 budget a 10% discount sells 1,000 of goods at list for 900 (+20%). The 25% step ends with everything sold, also for 900. Past 25% you only give stock away. Never use it when the budget already covers everything: the price just falls.
Buying side
Demand Discount uses the same odds, and a walk-out loses the whole deal. For an item you can get elsewhere, the 10% step costs about 91% of the price per item actually bought, and loses the deal 12% of the time. Do not gamble on a one-off lot you need.
Blackmail and Threaten
Blackmail works only on Wanted criminals. Threaten works only on Augs, from day 12. Either one on the wrong target always fails.
| Move | Works on | Chance | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| Blackmail (20%) | Wanted criminals only | 60 plus a reputation term (reputation / 4, doubled if negative); +15% for event customers | 20% better prices both ways; the trade costs reputation |
| Threaten (20%) | Augs only (from day 12) | Always works on an Aug | 20% better prices both ways; no reputation from the trades |
| Either on the wrong target | Anyone else | Always fails | 50% they leave (-10 rep), else they stay (-7 rep) |
- Neither works on Security officers. After either, Offer Discount and Offer Markup are closed to that customer.
- The community says Blackmail also works on criminal sellers of serious contraband or stolen goods and fails on innocents only half the time. The game data says a failed Blackmail on an innocent always fails and costs 7 to 10 reputation. Game data wins.
The Deal Maker machine
The machine has a value of 400 and draws 25 power a use. Efficiency and Performance modules cut that to 25 minus 25 x (Efficiency + Performance) / 100, at least 1. It is usable once per customer. It adds 10 plus the module Quality divided by 10 (cut to a whole number) to the accept chance of Add Markup, Demand Discount and Blackmail, and to nothing else.
What a trade does to reputation
Each trade gives value x multiplier / 400 reputation, so ₵1,000 of trade is 2.5 reputation.
- The multiplier is 1.0 for most customers and 2.0 or 3.0 for a few (Security officers, the Food Bank). Lower Levels trades count x0.66, Upper Levels x1.2, the Diplomatic perk x1.33.
- A "nice" offer adds to the multiplier: Offer Discount or Offer Markup at 10, 25, 50, 75% adds +0.65, +1.2, +2.0, +2.9. An accepted Add Markup or Demand Discount turns the multiplier to -0.5, -1.5, -3 or -5.
- A sale where the customer's budget capped the payment adds +1 to the multiplier. Our Thief's budget of ₵242 capped a 72 ingot sale on day 25.
- A customer cannot pay more than their remaining budget. If you sell anyway, you are paid only what is left.