Probably Stolen Guide

Mistakes to avoid

The hard lessons from our first playthrough, and the beliefs that are wrong.

  • Our playthrough played without a plan and was on course to own the shop around day 100 to 120. The plan in this guide owns it on day 49 at 12,000.
  • The biggest gaps: joining the Appraisers on day 29 instead of day 8, hoarding Favor for 18 days, an idle furnace, and refusing Georgio's loan.
  • Three choices cost real money or a story branch for good: the Landlord's water vending machine (+₵150 rent that never goes away), refusing Eleanor on day 29, and pressing Call Next before choosing Serpico's gift.
  • Most beliefs in the community and in our early notes about prices, multipliers, flux and the furnace are wrong in small but costly ways. The table near the end fixes them.
  • Our second playthrough (a plan-led week 1 to week 5) made smaller but real misses: a missed Lafleur on day 3, a half-empty Energy Cell run dry on day 14, all Food sold the day before a 750 budget Foodie Tourist, and three wanted visitors passed unseen. They are in the tables below.
  • Rule of thumb: look at the counter and the negotiation tab, check every face against the Wanted List, read every document the day it arrives, and never leave the case empty without a reason.

Privacy · Unofficial fan guide